Pruebe esto primero
Elija un solo formato y déle de 6 a 8 semanas
Los dos limpiadores grandes cuestan mucho menos por mililitro. El gel pequeño se acerca más al formato sin aclarado usado en la mayor parte de la escasa evidencia.
Misma concentración · distinto tiempo de contacto
Tres opciones con ácido salicílico al 2 % para puntos negros
Qué le ofrece esta página: Qué formato comprar, por qué el precio del envase no es el precio por uso y cuándo juzgar el resultado.
La respuesta corta
Qué hacer después
No use dos productos con ácido salicílico a la vez. Si el limpiador no ha ayudado a las 8 semanas, pruebe el gel sin aclarado en su lugar, no además.
Lo que esta página no puede decirle
El coste por 100 mL no es el coste por tratamiento aquí: un producto se aclara y el otro permanece en la piel.
Los tres productos
Los precios son una observación fechada, no una oferta vigente.
Gel sin aclarado · el más cercano al formato estudiado
CeraVe Acne Control Gel
$52.40 por 100 mL2% salicylic acid · 40 mL tube
Ver la verificación de la fórmula (en inglés)
Leímos la lista de ingredientes del envase de este mercado · comprobado el 2026-08-23
The Canadian label is for ages 12 and older. Longer contact may mean more irritation; start slowly and seek care if acne is painful, scarring, or not improving.
Limpiador grande con aclarado · barato por mililitro
CeraVe Acne Control Cleanser
$5.46 por 100 mL2% salicylic acid · 473 mL pump
Ver la verificación de la fórmula (en inglés)
Leímos la lista de ingredientes del envase de este mercado · comprobado el 2026-08-23
Brief contact may be easier to tolerate but is not proof of equal effect to a leave-on product. Clay changes shine temporarily, not oil production.
Limpiador grande con aclarado · precio de envase más bajo al comprobarlo
Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash Fragrance Free
$4.82 por 100 mL2% salicylic acid · 269 mL pump bottle
Ver la verificación de la fórmula (en inglés)
Buscamos una lista de ingredientes publicada para este envase y no la encontramos · comprobado el 2026-08-23
A well-documented 2% salicylic-acid wash with current Canadian directions and price data; brief contact is not proof of equal effect to a leave-on product.
Comprobación de fórmula del fabricante ↗Comprobación de fórmula del fabricante ↗
Qué cambiaOne is a small leave-on gel; two are large rinse-off cleansers. A leave-on usually uses less product per application and stays on the skin longer, so cost per 100 mL is not cost per treatment.
Las verificaciones, lado a lado
One question per row. The green check marks that row's better answer — there is no overall winner.
| Verificación | Acne Control Gelleave-on · 40 mL | Acne Control Cleanserrinse-off · 473 mL | Oil-Free Acne Washrinse-off · 269 mL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time on the skinper the directions | No rinse stepa thin layer stays on after cleansing | Rinsed offlather, then "rinse well" | Rinsed offlather, massage, then rinse |
| Do studies back this type?guidelines, reviews & studies · through Aug 25, 2026 | Mejor respuesta de esta fila.Thina 2024 dermatologists' guideline gives salicylic acid a weak recommendation, on low-quality evidence | Indirectsmall cleanser studies exist; none estimates this exact current wash | Indirectformula-family study is uncontrolled and the current-formula bridge is incomplete |
Todo lo anterior en detalle: las verificaciones lado a lado, lo que halló cada estudio, lo que dicen las etiquetas y nuestras fuentes.
La evidencia detallada que sigue está escrita en inglés.
Por qué esta respuesta
Resumen de la comparación
Does the cheaper bottle provide better value?
Cost per 100 mL is not cost per treatment here: one product is rinsed off and the other stays on.
For volume-price context only, the two rinse-off cleansers were far cheaper per 100 mL than the leave-on gel. Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash was the lowest package price when checked. This does not establish lower cost per treatment or equal results across formats.
All three state 2% salicylic acid. The two large cleansers are far cheaper per millilitre; the gel is closer to the leave-on format used in much of the limited evidence. Pick one format, not several salicylic-acid products, and judge it at 6–8 weeks.
Qué coincide
All three state 2% salicylic acid and are intended for acne-prone skin. Every package is measured in millilitres.
Qué cambia
One is a small leave-on gel; two are large rinse-off cleansers. A leave-on usually uses less product per application and stays on the skin longer, so cost per 100 mL is not cost per treatment.
Límite de la evidencia
Evidence on this page supports the ingredient, product type, or prevention step. It doesn't prove any one of these exact products is better.
Lo que los estudios encontraron de verdad
All three state 2% salicylic acid. Rinse-off cleanser studies exist, but the maintained evidence set contains no controlled exact-current-product estimate for any of these three Canadian packages. The useful comparison remains label, format, dated price, and evidence directness—not a claim that the cheapest bottle works best.
—Our search found no study of this exact product
CeraVe Acne Control Gel
The maintained ClinicalTrials.gov and PubMed searches returned no record naming this gel. Those searches also identified no finished-product measurement of blackheads and no comparison with the cleanser on this page as of August 22, 2026.
Salvedad: The search covers ClinicalTrials.gov and PubMed; a study that was never registered and never indexed would not appear.
—Studies of similar cleansers only, not this one
CeraVe Acne Control Cleanser
A 42-person study, run with the maker's involvement, used a very similar 2% salicylic-acid cleanser containing gluconolactone, hectorite, niacinamide and three ceramides for 28 days. Spot counts and the examining doctor's scores both improved over the month. But nobody was compared against a different cleanser or none at all, the report gives no sense of how much of that change could be chance, and the cleanser tested is not confirmed to be the bottle sold in Canada today.
Salvedad: The result is a close-formula, uncontrolled signal. It cannot show what the cleanser caused, quantify this Canadian product's effect, or establish equivalence with the leave-on gel.
Levin et al., Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2026 ↗Salicylic acid trial record →
—Studies of similar formulas only, not this one
Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash Fragrance Free
A 35-person Kenvue formula-family study of a 2% salicylic-acid cleanser reported a 33.7% reduction in total lesions from the starting point after 12 weeks. It had no control group and does not establish that the tested formula is this exact current Canadian fragrance-free wash.
Salvedad: A formula-family before-and-after percentage is not a causal effect or an exact-product result. The Canadian label and current price remain separate product facts.
Hussain et al., Journal of Drugs in Dermatology, 2025 ↗Salicylic acid trial record →
Otras fuentes consultadas
Exact-product searches were checked through August 22, 2026, and additional evidence was reviewed through August 25. The maintained evidence set includes a small crossover and uncontrolled cleanser/formula-family studies, but no controlled exact-current-product result for these three Canadian packages. Ingredient evidence, indirect cleanser signals, and label quality are shown separately.
Cómo buscamos estudios sobre estos productos exactos
Última búsqueda:
Última revisión de los resultados:
For each evidence row, search the quoted evidence-row product name, then the quoted brand plus the distinctive product-name tokens. A brand-wide statement additionally requires a quoted brand-name search. Formula codes are added only when an official or study source discloses them.
- ClinicalTrials.gov: Registered studies returned by exact product-name, brand-plus-product-name, and disclosed internal formula-code searches.
- PubMed: Indexed records returned by exact product-name and brand-plus-distinctive-product-token searches.
Lo que esto no le dice: A negative maintained search is a dated coverage statement, not proof that no study exists in another database, language, registry, sponsor archive, unpublished report, or differently named formula.
Lo que dicen las etiquetas
Same active strength: 2% salicylic acid. All three publish directions and cautions; licence, fragrance and age wording differ, so those facts stay product-specific below.
| Dato de etiqueta | CeraVeAcne Control Gel | CeraVeAcne Control Cleanser | NeutrogenaOil-Free Acne Wash Fragrance Free |
|---|---|---|---|
| Format | Leave-on geldirections have no rinse step | Rinse-off face wash"Rinse well" | Rinse-off face washlather, massage, then rinse |
| Amount per use | "A thin layer"cerave.ca · not a measurable amount | "A dime-size amount"cerave.ca · not a measurable amount | Amount not measuredbrand directions say apply to hands and lather |
| How often | Start once daily, up to 2–3× dailycerave.ca · patch-test a small area for 3 days first | Morning and eveningcerave.ca | Start once daily, up to 2–3× dailyneutrogena.ca · reduce frequency if dryness occurs |
| Licence | Health Canada licence 80117322per Health Canada's licence register | Health Canada licence 80124317per Health Canada's licence register | Canadian OTC acne-drug labelcurrent product page and package directions; licence number not mapped here |
| Extra cautions | Also contains AHAs — use sunscreen on treated skinHealth Canada licence risk text | Avoid the eye areacerave.ca | Avoid eyes; reduce use if dry or peelingneutrogena.ca |
Sources: CeraVe and Neutrogena Canadian product pages, Health Canada's Licensed Natural Health Products Database, and Walmart Canada. CeraVe prices were checked July 30, 2026; Neutrogena was checked Aug 22, 2026. Label authorization is not evidence that one finished product works better.
Notas y fuentes
- "Thin" evidence: the 2024 American Academy of Dermatology guideline conditionally recommends salicylic acid for acne (low certainty). As summarized in the guideline, that rests largely on one trial of 0.5% salicylic acid — a weaker strength than these products — which cut inflamed spots 25% more and blackheads (open comedones) 11% more than a non-medicated control, with no difference for whiteheads (closed comedones).
- The 2020 Cochrane review did not pool a salicylic-acid estimate; the comparisons it reviewed were low or very-low quality. Two major studies comparing many acne treatments left salicylic acid out entirely.
- Rinse-off evidence exists but remains indirect. A 30-person crossover compared a 2% salicylic-acid cleanser with a 10% benzoyl-peroxide wash: the abstract reported a within-period comedone signal for salicylic acid, while the Cochrane review found no significant between-group comedone difference and the publication provides no usable effect magnitude. Newer close-formula CeraVe and Neutrogena formula-family cleanser studies are uncontrolled. None estimates either exact current Canadian wash, and formula, pH, contact time, and free-acid delivery limit transfer.
- Our acne evidence index tracks 11 registered salicylic-acid studies, 4 with posted results. These studied the ingredient, not these products.
- The 6–8-week window comes from both products' Health Canada licence text: stop use if improvement is not apparent within 6–8 weeks. The cleanser's 12+ age comes from its licence record; its brand page shows no age.
- Per-wash cost cannot be calculated reliably because the label directions are not measurable volumes. Package sizes and unit prices are shown instead.
- ClinicalTrials.gov and PubMed searches through Aug 22, 2026 identified no head-to-head study of these three exact products.
Después de la evidencia
Ver precios actuales en Amazon
Como afiliado de Amazon, Skinlogie obtiene ingresos por compras que cumplen los requisitos, sin costo adicional para usted. Los enlaces llevan a fichas exactas cuando están verificadas.